Online Billing & Payments Aegis Customer : (800) 233-2160 Claims : 800-233-2160 Visit Website Claims site American Modern Customer : 1-888-451-4847 Claims : 800-375-2075 Visit Website Claims site American Collectors Customer: 1-888-451-4847 Claims : 888-421-2858 Visit Website Claims site Employers Customer : (888) 682-6671Claims : 855-365-6010 Visit Website Claims site Foremost Customer : 888-383-4244 Claims : 800-527-3907 Visit Website Claims site Hagerty Phone: 1888-220-9565 Phone: 800-385-0274 Visit Website Claims site ICW Insurance Customer : 800-877-1111 Claims: 855-442-9252 Visit Website Claims site ICAT Customer : (303)447-1155 Claims : 866-789-4228 Visit Website Claims site Kemper Insurance Customer : 866-860-9348 Claims: 888-252-2799 Visit Website Claims site Liberty Mutual Customer : 866-290-2920 Claims : 844-325-2467 Visit Website Claims site Mercury Customer : (888) 682-6671Claims : 800-503-3724 Visit Website Claims site Markel Customer : 888-642-4968 Claims : 888-642-4968 Visit Website Claims site National General Customer : 888-325-1190 Claims : 800-468-3466 Visit Website Claims site Nationwide Customer : 877-669-6877 Claims: 800-421-3535 Visit Website Claims site Progressive Customer : 1-888-671-4405 Claims : 800-776-4737 Visit Website Claims site Philadelphia Customer : (303)447-1155 Claims : 866-789-4228 Visit Website Claims site Pacific Specialty Customer : 800-303-5000 Claims : 800-962-1172 Visit Website Claims site Safeco Customer : 800-332-3226 Claims : 800-332-3226 Visit Website Claims site Stillwater Insurance Customer : 855-712-4092 Claims : 800-220-1351 Visit Website Claims Site Travelers Customer : 1.800.842.5075 Claims : 800-252-4633 Visit Website Claims site The Hartford Customer : 866-467-8730 Claims : 855-442-9252 Visit Website Claims Ssite